Tuesday, April 6, 2010

Ghosting and Antighosting

What is ghosting and antighosting, anyway?

According to Antighosting Explained: "Some keyboard keys don’t work when multiple keys are pressed simultaneously. The key presses that don’t show up on the computer or seem to have disappeared are said to have been ghosted. On most keyboards, even some that are explicitly marketed as Anti-Ghosting, this happens with many three key combinations.

Want to know if your own computer keyboard will work with Plover? Test its antighosting abilities online with the Keyboard Ghosting Demo. As far as I know, the only true antighosting keyboards on the market are the SideWinder X4, Razer Tarantula, Stealth 7G, and Logitech G19. The SideWinder is by far the cheapest of these, but if you have one of the others lying around, you should give Plover a try.

The Sidewinder FAQ states that the X4 can recognize up to 17 alphanumeric keypresses at a time. But a steno machine has 22 keys, and all of them can theoretically be pressed at a time! I was worried that this might be a problem, but then I looked in my actual steno dictionary, and noticed that the longest single stroke (STKPWHRAOEUPBS, an alternate stroke for "guidelines") only used 14 keys. So maybe there are some people out there whose dictionaries contain lots of 18-to-22-key strokes, in which case they'll probably have to upgrade to the more expensive antighosting keyboards. If you're like me, and your steno dictionary stroke length maxes out at 17 or fewer, you're probably okay.

True antighosting is paramount when using a qwerty keyboard as a steno machine. After a few weeks with the SideWinder X4, I'm happy to report that its key recognition capabilities seem to be flawless. For a $60 keyboard, that's no mean feat. I can't recommend it highly enough. Microsoft isn't giving me any kickbacks, either.


Stan Sakai said...

i'm going to go sidewinder hunting tomorrow. after seeing that video i just had to manually put my jaw back up into closed position. i just bought a new fountain pen yesterday for 40$ and i could have a pseudo - yet fully functional digital steno machine for 60 bucks?!

Stan Sakai said...

forgot to ask. how are the key presses? you said some of the more intricate outlines are a bit awkward but overall how is it? i feel like my steno machine has a considerably bigger layout than a qwerty keyboard? (in reference to the size of the keys and the spacing. And you said it doesn't really matter that the keys are staggered on qwerty rather than exactly aligned on the steno layout?

Abby Bayne said...

Sidewinder just came today, I'm anxious to try it out. I'll let you know how it's going!

Mirabai Knight said...

Abigail: Awesome! I'm gonna try to get your dictionary converted and sent back to you as quickly as I can so you can start playing around with it.

Mirabai Knight said...

Stan: So sorry I haven't answered these yet. The days have just gotten away from me. Anyway, I find the key presses fairly comfortable, after a brief adjustment period. The keypads help a lot, since they're able to solve the alignment problem. Sonja is going to try to do it without the keypads, so we'll see how much the misalignment bothers her. I don't think I could handle it if they were misaligned, though, which is why the keypads are a must for me. In terms of size, I find it pretty comfortable. It's definitely smaller than the footprint of my steno machine, but I don't have to squeeze in too tight. I have relatively small fingers, though, so your mileage may vary.